I taped on October 6 a 46 minute interview on developments in Ethiopia and the Horn of Africa with ESAT Ethiopia Insight. It caters primarily to the Ethiopian diaspora.
Thank you so much Amb. David Shinn for this very interesting interview. But one can see that you made a great deal of effort not confront important issues. For example, you were asked to comment on ethnic federalism but left it as an issue that should be addressed by 83% "peasants". I think that was not a good answer. Another, you seem to think that dissent toward the Meles regime is mainly a Diaspora affair...All in all, you were to careful not to express your honest opinions on some issues...
I saw the interview. It was good. You were very mesasured and balanced. That was good. Your tone was a bit tough and sharp. I sensed one thing from that and generally from that interview and that is ; you are a bit critical and view the Ethiopian Diaspora with suspicion. That is how the Meles' regime views it too. They have this opinion that the Ethiopian Diaspora espcailly those that are political are a bit extereme. That is not true. The Ethioipian Diaspora knows the situtaion of the Ethiopian peasant better than Meles does. Our partents, relatives are families are peasants. We are with them always. Had we been careless about their safety and the realities they live in, we would have taken consequenatil measures that would have jeopardiesed their lives. But we are fair too...we need their safety and prosperity and our movement is farmer/peasant focused or concerned. we may appear extereme because we live in democratic countries and emit our anger and frustration more vocally and loudly than those in the country. Therefore, please sharpen your misperception about the Ethiopian Diaspora.People like you are important to us...so stand with us too.
China and Africa: The Next Decade (Keynote address on 1 February 2013 during a conference on China in Africa at the University of Denver in Denver, Colorado)
China's Engagement in Africa (chapter in the CSIS Africa Program report: Africa Policy in the George W. Bush Years: Recommendations for the Obama Administration, January 2009)
Challenges Facing Somalia (House Subcommittee on Africa, Global Health, and Human Rights and the Subcommittee on Terrorism, Nonproliferation and Trade, July 7, 2011)
Ethiopian Armed Groups (The Future of Armed Groups in Africa, conference hosted by State Department’s Bureau of Intelligence and Research and U.S. Africa Command, Germany, Nov. 13-14, 2009)
Remarks on the Horn of Africa (Conference hosted by the Center for Strategic and International Studies and the American Academy of Diplomacy, Oct. 29, 2009, Washington, D.C.)
how mach TPLF paid you
ReplyDeleteThank you so much Amb. David Shinn for this very interesting interview. But one can see that you made a great deal of effort not confront important issues. For example, you were asked to comment on ethnic federalism but left it as an issue that should be addressed by 83% "peasants". I think that was not a good answer. Another, you seem to think that dissent toward the Meles regime is mainly a Diaspora affair...All in all, you were to careful not to express your honest opinions on some issues...
ReplyDeleteThank you so much for your insight. It is great. I am sure you will also educate Helen Daniel, who seems to be not pleased with your interview
ReplyDeletehttp://addisvoice.com/2011/11/dr-david-shinn-and-his-peasant-based-analysis/
I saw the interview. It was good. You were very mesasured and balanced. That was good. Your tone was a bit tough and sharp. I sensed one thing from that and generally from that interview and that is ; you are a bit critical and view the Ethiopian Diaspora with suspicion. That is how the Meles' regime views it too. They have this opinion that the Ethiopian Diaspora espcailly those that are political are a bit extereme. That is not true. The Ethioipian Diaspora knows the situtaion of the Ethiopian peasant better than Meles does. Our partents, relatives are families are peasants. We are with them always. Had we been careless about their safety and the realities they live in, we would have taken consequenatil measures that would have jeopardiesed their lives. But we are fair too...we need their safety and prosperity and our movement is farmer/peasant focused or concerned. we may appear extereme because we live in democratic countries and emit our anger and frustration more vocally and loudly than those in the country.
ReplyDeleteTherefore, please sharpen your misperception about the Ethiopian Diaspora.People like you are important to us...so stand with us too.