The Official Blog of Amb. David H. Shinn: Somalia: Criticism of Clan Federalism

skip to main | skip to sidebar

The Official Blog of Amb. David H. Shinn

Pages

Home
About Amb. Shinn
Amb. Shinn's Books

Thursday, February 7, 2013

Somalia: Criticism of Clan Federalism

Mohamed M. Uluso wrote a brief piece for Pambazuka News on 6 February 2013 titled "Clan Federalism Tears Somalia Apart." Uluso argued that clan federalism only expands the problems of bad governance.

Labels: clans, federalism, governance, Somalia

Newer Post Older Post Home

Follow (click image below)

Search This Blog

China-Africa Relations

China-Africa Bibliography (July 15, 2023)
Syllabus for China-Africa Graduate Course (21 June 2023)
China's Security in Red Sea Region (MEI, 18 May 2021)
Covid-19 and Chinese Soft Power in Africa (10 May 2020)
China in Africa Testimony (8 May 2020)
Forum on China-Africa Cooperation Meets the Belt and Road (East Asia Forum - 18 October 2018)
China's Just another Great Power in Africa (East Asia Forum, 17 May 2018)
Deciphering Chinese Investment in Nigeria (US-China Focus 6 October 2017)
China's Power Projection in the Western Indian Ocean (China Brief, 20 April 2017)
Protection of American Nationals and Interests in Africa (Paper delivered at a conference in Beijing on 9 March 2017)
Comparing American and Chinese Business Models in Africa (Remarks made at the Woodrow Wilson Center in Washington, D.C. on 15 November 2016)
Africa as China's Laboratory for Third World Security Cooperation (China Brief, 6 July 2016)
The Environmental Impact of China's FDI in Africa (Winter 2016 issue of Cornell International Law Journal)
China's Growing Security Relationship with Africa (Remarks at Michigan State University on 28 January 2016)
China's Investment in Africa: Environmental Implications and the Law (Remarks at Washington and Lee University School of Law in Lexington, Virginia on 23 October 2015)
The Evolving China-Africa Security Relationship (Remarks made on 26 August 2015 at a conference in Cape Town hosted by the Centre for Chinese Studies at Stellenbosch University)
China-Africa Infrastructure Financing (Remarks at Center for Strategic and International Studies on 29 July 2015)
China, Africa and Food Security (Remarks at Yale University on 8 July 2015)
Environmental Impact of China's Investment in Africa (Remarks at Yale University School of Forestry and Environmental Studies on 4 April 2015)
China's Interest in and Strategy towards Africa (English-language original of article published in Italian-language Italianieuropei in March 2015)
China and the United States in Africa: Cooperation or Competition? (Remarks at the University of Illinois on 16 February 2015)
Ethiopia and China (Paper presented at the 13th International Conference of Africanists in Moscow, 27-30 May 2014)
China Confronts Terrorism in Africa (China-US Focus, Nov. 18, 2013)
China's Response to the Islamist Threat in Mali (Published in 21 June 2013 issue of China-US Focus)
China and Africa: Challenges and Predictions (Speech to the Cosmopolitan Club in New York on 8 April 2013)
China and Africa in the Xi Jinping Era (Published in The Diplomat on 25 March 2013)
China and Africa: The Next Decade (Keynote address on 1 February 2013 during a conference on China in Africa at the the University of Denver)
China and Africa: What Do We Know? How Do We Know It (Remarks during panel discussion at the African Studies Association conference in Philadelphia on 29 November 2012)
China's Investments in Africa (Published in China-US Focus on 1 November 2012)
China and Security Issues in Africa (Remarks at conference on China, Canada and Africa in Ottawa on 20 September 2012)
China, Sudan and South Sudan (19 September 2012 comment for The Diplomat)
China and Mozambique (Remarks in Washington on 30 July 2012)
China, Africa and Implications for the US (Commentary posted on China-US Focus website on 12 July 2012)
Transcript on China-Africa Business Links (Carnegie Council in New York on 15 June 2012)
Podcast on China-Africa Business Links (Carnegie Council in New York on 15 June 2012)
China's Security Policy in Africa and the Western Indian Ocean (International Affairs Forum - 15 May 2012)
Emerging Powers in Africa (Remarks on 4 May 2012 at the National Defense University in Washington)
China-Africa Testimony (House Africa Subcommittee, 29 March 2012)
The United States Reassesses the China-Africa Relationship (French translation appeared in issue 30 of Outre-Terre, published in January 2012.)
China-Africa Relations: The Big Picture (2011 Achebe Colloquium, Brown University, Providence, Rhode Island, 4 December 2011)
China and the Horn of Africa (Middle East Studies Association, Washington, D.C., Dec. 2, 2011)
United States and China in Africa: Advancing the Diplomatic Agenda (Remarks originally made at Virginia Military Institute 4 November 2011 and then carried in International Policy Digest on 14 November 2011)
China's Growing Role in Africa: Implications for U.S. Policy (Senate Committee on Foreign Relations Subcommittee on African Affairs, Dirksen Senate Office Building, 1 Nov., 2011)
United States-China Collaboration on Health and Agricultutrre in Africa (Center for Sategic and International Studies [D.C.] and China Institute of International Studies [Beijing], Beijing, May 24, 2011)
The Impact of China's Growing Influence in Africa (European Financial Review, April-May, 2011)
North African Revolutions and Protests Challenge Chinese Diplomacy (China Brief, Vol. 11, No. 6, April 8, 2011)
The Role of China in Africa: Trade, Investment and Aid (Social Investment Forum International Working Group, Washington, D.C., May 18, 2010)
China and the Conflict in Darfur (The Brown Journal of World Affairs, fall/winter 2009)
Africa: The United States and China Court the Continent (Journal of International Affairs, Spring/Summer 2009)
China’s Involvement in African Conflict Zones (Jamestown Foundation, National Press Club, May 20, 2009)
Chinese Involvement in African Conflict Zones (China Brief, April 2009)
Africa at the Crossroads (chapter in Crossroads Africa: Perspectives on U.S.-China-Africa Security Affairs, CENSA, June 2009)
Comparing Engagement with Africa by China and the United States (Indiana University, March 6 - 7, 2009)
China's Engagement in Africa (chapter in the CSIS Africa Program report: Africa Policy in the George W. Bush Years: Recommendations for the Obama Administration, January 2009)
Responding to China in Africa (American Foreign Policy Council, June 2008)
China's Relations with Zimbabwe, Sudan and the DRC ( Remarks at the New England School of Law, 15 March 2008)
An Opportunistic Ally ( Harvard International Review, Summer 2007)
Africa, China, the United States, and Oil (CSIS Africa Policy Forum, May 2007)
Africa, China and Health Care (PDF, Inside AISA, nos. 3 & 4, Oct./Dec., 2006, pp. 14-16)
The China Factor in African Ethics (Policy Innovations, Dec. 2006)
Africa and China’s Global Activism (NDU, June 20, 2006)
Dueling Priorities For Beijing in the Horn of Africa (China Brief, Oct. 2005)
China's Approach to East, North and the Horn of Africa (U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission, July 2005)

East Africa and the Horn

Outside Powers Vie for Influence in Red Sea Region (27 November 2020)
Red Sea Security (May 2020 podcast)
Competition in the Red Sea: Perspectives from the African Side (Remarks on 7 March 2019)
Red Sea Region and U.S. Interests (USIP interview 19 December 2018)
The Political Crisis in Ethopia (Remarks by David Shinn at panel during African Studies Association conference in Washington on 3 December 2016)
Challenges to US Diplomacy: Dealing with Terrorism and Instability in the Horn of Africa (Remarks at the Osher Lifelong Learning Institute in Annandale, Virginia on 13 October 2015)
Neither Desperate Nor Stronger: The Adaptation of Al Shabaab (E-International Relations 3 July 2015)
Somalia, Al-Shabaab, the Region and U.S. Policy (Remarks at William and Mary in Williamsburg, VA on 8 April 2015)
US Policy in the Horn of Africa (Remarks at GWU Institute for Global and International Studies in October 2014)
U.S.Policy in the Horn of Africa (Paper delivered in Moscow in May 2014 at 13th International Conference of Africanists)
Ethiopia: Muslim-Christian Relations (Remarks at Bolling Air Force Base on 16 January 2014)
Time to Bring Eritrea in from the Cold (posted on African Arguments on 13 January 2014)
Somalia: Origin, Development and Future of AMISOM (University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota on 19 October 2013)
Al-Shabaab in the Aftermath of the Attack on Nairobi's Westgate Mall (Published by eInternationalRelations on 10 October 2013)
eInternationalRelations on 10 October 2013) U.S. Security Policy in East Africa and the Horn (Published in World Politics Review on 20 February 2013)
People to People and Ethiopian Healthcare (Remarks made at symposium hosted by People to People at the University of Kentucky on 27 November 2012)
Somalia: Security, AMISOM, Governance, Al-Shabaab and the Future (Commentary on e-International Relations 26 September 2012)
Somalia, Somaliland and the US Dual Track Policy (18 May 2012 Somaliland Conference at Hilton Dulles Hotel in Virginia)
International Efforts to Counter Al-Shabaab (e-International Relations website, 20 February 2012)
Al-Shabaab and Somalia in the 21st Century (Jan. 2012, New York City)
East Africa and the Horn (Chapter 4 of Al-Qaida after Ten Years of War published by Marine Corps University Press in 2011)
Republic of South Sudan: Statehood and the Challenges Ahead (PowerPoint presentation delivered in Italy, Oct. 27, 2011
Somali Youth radicalization (French and English versions, Royal Canadian Mounted Police Gazette, Vol. 73, No. 2, 2011)
U.S. Policy towards the Horn of Africa (Western Michigan University, Kalamazoo, Michigan, Sept. 30, 2011)
A Proposed US Regional Strategy towards the Horn of Africa: Conflict Resolution at Local and Regional Levels (Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, Washington, D.C., 7 September, 2011)
Water and Security in Africa (Hosted by U.S. State Department, AFRICOM, Arlington, Va., July 21-22, 2011)
Challenges Facing Somalia (House Subcommittee on Africa, Global Health, and Human Rights and the Subcommittee on Terrorism, Nonproliferation and Trade, July 7, 2011)
Sudan - Rule of Law Deployments (Hosted by Walker Institute, University of South Carolina, Coumbia, S.C., 1 July, 2011)
Revolutionary Winds from North to South of the Sahara: Wishful Thinking? (University Club, Washington, D.C., 10 June, 2011)
Al Shabaab's Foreign Threat to Somalia (Orbis, Vol. 55, Issue 2, 2011, pages 203-215)
Al-Qaeda, Al-Shabaab and Somalia (Selfridge Air National Guard, Mount Clemens, Mich., Feb. 15, 2011)
Somalia: Promoting Peace and Preventing Youth Radicalization (Canadian Friends of Somalia conference, Ottawa, Dec. 6-7, 2010)
Interview (Awramba Times, Dec. 1, 2010)
Al-Shabaab tries to take control in Somalia (Foreign Policy Research Institute, Nov., 2010)
Libyan policy in the Horn of Africa (Center for Naval Analyses, Oct. 25, 2010)
Remarks to Somali Transitional Federal Government Members of Parliament (Mayflower Renaissance Hotel, June 24, Washington, D.C.)
Somalia and the International Community: Facing Reality (9th Horn of Africa Conference Focus on Somalia, June 4, Lund, Sweden)
United States-Somali Relations: Local, National and International Dimensions (Center for African Studies, Ohio State University, April 26, 2010)
A Vision for the Horn of Africa (Advocacy for Ethiopia, Ethiopian National Priorities Consultative Process, Virginia, April 9, 2010)
Challenges to Peace and Stability in the Horn of Africa (World Affairs Council of N. California, March 12, 2010)
Ways to Contribute to the Future of Ethiopia (Ethiopian American Youth Initiative, Ethiopian Embassy, Washington, D.C., Jan. 2, 2010)
The Intensity, Spread and Economics of Somali Piracy (Controlling Maritime Piracy, Harvard Kennedy School, Dec. 10-12, 2009)
Al-Shabaab and the Future of Somalia (Jamestown Foundation conference, National Press Club, Dec. 9, 2009)
Ethiopian Armed Groups (The Future of Armed Groups in Africa, conference hosted by State Department’s Bureau of Intelligence and Research and U.S. Africa Command, Germany, Nov. 13-14, 2009)
Remarks on the Horn of Africa (Conference hosted by the Center for Strategic and International Studies and the American Academy of Diplomacy, Oct. 29, 2009, Washington, D.C.)
Somalia: Rise of Piracy and Maritime Insecurity (Maritime Piracy Summit 2009, Virginia, Sept. 22, 2009)
Testimony before U.S. Senate Committee on Foreign Relations (Hearing on Sudan, July 30, 2009, PDF format)
Rise of Piracy and Other Maritime Insecurity in Somalia (Somali piracy conference hosted by the National Maritime Intelligence Center and the Office of Naval Intelligence, April 7, 2009)
Somalia’s New Government and the Challenge of Al-Shabab (PDF file, CTC Sentinel, March 2009)
Horn of Africa: Priorities and Recommendations (Hearing before the House Subcommittee on State and Foreign Operations Committee on Appropriations, March 12, 2009)
Implications of Terrorism and Counterterrorism in the Horn of Africa (at Horn of Africa Conference - VII, Sweden, October 2008)
Evaluating U.S. Policy Objectives and Options on the Horn of Africa (before Senate Committee on Foreign Relations, 11 March 2008)
Ethiopia and Sudan: Conflict and Cooperation in the Nile Valley (chapter in Narrating the Nile: Politics, Identities, Cultures, 2008)
Somalia: Prospects for Lasting Peace (Joint Summit of European Parliament and US House of Representatives, 8 July 2007)
Al-Qaeda in East Africa and the Horn (Journal of Conflict Studies, Summer 2007)
Exploring a Comprehensive Stabilization, Reconstruction, and Counterterrorism Strategy for Somalia (before Senate Committee on Foreign Relations, 6 February 2007)
Somalia: Regional Involvement and Implications for US Policy (Paper presented on 4 October 2006 to the American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research in Washington, D.C.)
Nile Basin Relations: Egypt, Sudan and Ethiopia (July 2006)
Somalia: U.S. Government Policy and Challenges (before Senate Committee on Foreign Relations, 11 July 2006)
Avoiding a Water War in the Nile Basin (Power Point at Los Alamos National Laboratory on March 16, 2006)
Avoiding a Water War in the Nile Basin (Presentation at Los Alamos National Laboratory on March 16, 2006)
Somaliland: The Little Country that Could (CSIS Africa Notes, Nov. 2004)
Fighting Terrorism in East Africa and the Horn (Foreign Service Journal, Sept. 2004)

Miscellaneous

Non-Regional Actors in Red Sea Basin (Remarks made in Amman, Jordan, on 27 April 2019)
Five Second Tier Non-Western External Actors in Africa (21 May 2018)
Economic Diplomacy and Africa's Foreign Partners: Focus on the United States and China (Presentation at Fudan University in Shanghai, China, on 27 June 2017)
The Indian Ocean and Deep Seabed Mining (Posted on Young Diplomats website 3 February 2017)
China's WTO Compliance: The US Reaction (China Policy Institute posting on 14 November 2016)
Poverty and Terrorism in Africa (Article in the 2016 summer/fall issue of the Georgetown Journal of International Affairs)
Turkey-Africa Relations (Remarks at the Africa Center for Strategic Studies in Arlington, Virginia on 31 Oct. 2016)
Africa's Changing Partnerships over the Next Decade (Remarks at the National Press Club in Washington, D.C. on 7 June 2016)
Hizmet in Africa (Presentation in Sao Paulo, Brazil, on 19 May 2016 at an international conference on the Gulen Movement)
Turkey-Africa Relations 2016 (Remarks at the Turkish-American Cultural Center in Madison, Wisconsin on 3 March 2016)
Turkey-Sub-Sahara Africa Relations (Paper published in September 2015 by Chatham House and presented in Istanbul)
Africa: The Good, the Bad, and the Future (Remarks at Yakima Rotary Club on 23 July 2015)
BRICS and Africa (Remarks made to the next generation of African security leaders on 19 March 2013)
Les pays BRICS et l'Afrique (Remarks made to the next generation of African security leaders on 19 March 2013)
African Union Peace Operations (Remarks at national security seminar at George Washington University on 7 December 2012)
Tolerance or War (Commentary distributed by Project Syndicate on 7 December 2012)
Emerging Powers in Africa Update (Remarks on 13 September 2012 at the National Defense University in Washington)
Turkey and the Horn of Africa (Remarks at Chatham House in London on 28 June 2012)
Ethics and Foreign Affairs (5 June 2012 Q and A with Carnegie Council for Ethics in International Affairs)
Emerging Powers in Africa (Remarks on 4 May 2012 at the National Defense University in Washington)
Water Crisis in Africa (Remarks at GWU on 9 April 2012)
Water and Security in Africa (Remarks at US State Department/AFRICOM Conference in Arlington, VA on 21-22 July 2011)
French Translation of Emerging Powers in Africa (Remarks at National Defense University in Washington on 15 June 2011)
Portuguese Translation of Emerging Powers in Africa (Remarks at National Defense University in Washington on 15 June 2011)
Democracy in Africa (Q and A with Journalist on 5 December 2010)
African Refugees and Immigrants (Remarks to Ethiopian Community Development Council on 3 May 2010)
Palestine - Visit to Nablus and Samaritan Community (Brief account of 22 June 2010 visit)
Palestine - Visit to Gaza (Account of 20-21 June 2010 visit to Gaza)
Palestine - Visit to Hebron (Brief account of 13 June 2010 visit)
US Policy Themes in Sub-Saharan Africa (Published by the Elliott School of International Affairs in 2004)

China-Africa Web Sites

Africa Files
African Economic Research Consortium
Centre for Chinese Studies, Stellenbosch University
Chatham House
China’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs
CSIS Africa Policy Forum
Forest Trends
Forum on China Africa Cooperation
French-language site
German Development Institute
Hong Kong Center on China’s Transnational Relations
Institute for Security Studies
Institute for Sustainable Development and International Relations
International Rivers
Jamestown Foundation China Brief
Open Democracy
Pambazuka News China-Africa Watch
Power and Interest News Report
South African Institute for International Affairs
The Brenthurst Foundation
Trade Law Centre for Southern Africa
UCLA Globalization Research Center – Africa
UK Department for International Development
University of Brussels

Horn of Africa Web Sites

Addis Standard
Association for Higher Education and Development
Daily Nation (Kenya)
Ethio Forum (news)
Ethio Media
Ethio.com (news)
Ethiopian Economic Association
Ethiopian Government News Agency
Ethiopian Institute for Non-Violence Education and Peace Studies
Ethiopian Medhin Democratic Party (opposition party)
Ethiopian Ministry of Foreign Affairs
Ethiopian Parliament
Ethiopian People's Revolutionary Democratic Front (ruling party's Web site)
Ethiopian People’s Revolutionary Party (opposition party)
Ethiopian Recycler (blog)
Ethiopian Review
Food Security and Nutriton Analysis Unit, Somalia
Forum for Social Studies
Global Policy Forum - Ethiopia and Eritrea
Horn Affairs
Information on Southern Ethiopia
Jimma Times
MediaETHIOPIA (news service)
National Archives and Library of Ethiopia
Nazret.com Ethiopian News Portal
Network of Ethiopian Muslims
Official Site of the Imperial Family of Ethiopia
Ogaden National Liberation Front (opposition party)
Ogaden Online (Somali and English language news with a focus on Somali issues in Ethiopia)
Ogadeni National Liberation Front
Oromo Federalist Democratic Movement (opposition party)
Oromo Liberation Front
People to People
SomaliaReport (Media MONITOR)
Standard (Kenya)
The Ethiopian American
The Fistula Foundation
The Sidama Concern
Tigrean International Solidarity for Justice and Democracy (opposition party)
UN Political Office (Somalia)
UNICEF
Walta Information Center (news service)

General Web Sites for Africa

Accord
Africa Intelligence
African Development Bank
African Union
allAfrica.com
Amnesty International
Arab League
Boston University African Studies Center
British Broadcasting Company
Center for Global Development
Center for Strategic and International Studies
Chiefs of state and cabinet members
CIA World Factbook
CNN
Combined Joint Task Force Horn of Africa
Committee to Protect Journalists
Common Market for Eastern and Southern Africa
Cornell University Africana Studies and Research Center
Council of Foreign Relations
East African Community
Enough
Export-Import Bank of the U.S.
Famine Early Warning Systems Network
Harvard University Committee on African Studies
Human Rights Watch Africa
Indiana University African Studies Program
Institute for Security Studies
Integrated Regional Information Networks (IRIN) Africa
Intergovernmental Authority on Development
International Boundaries Research Unit
International Crisis Group
International Monetary Fund
International Resources Group
Library of Congress Country Studies series
Life and Peace Institute Horn of Africa Bulletin
Massive bibliography on Africa
Michigan State University African Studies Center
Millennium Challenge Corporation
Mo Ibrahim Foundation
National Defense University Africa Center for Strategic Studies
National Endowment for Democracy
News about Africa
Nile Basin Initiative
Northwestern University African Studies Program
Organization for Social Science Research in Eastern and Southern Africa
Organization of the Islamic Conference
Overseas Private Investment Corporation
Program on International Policy Attitudes
Relief Web
Relief Web
The Carter Center
The George Washington University Africa Center for Health and Human Security
Thomsen Reuters Foundation
Transparency International
U.S. Agency for International Development
U.S. government press releases
U.S. State Department
UCLA African Studies Center
UN Development Programme
UN High Commissioner for Refugees
UN Office for the Coordinator of Humanitarian Affairs
UNICEF
United Nations
University of Florida Center for African Studies
University of Pennsylvania African Studies Center
University of Wisconsin African Studies Program
US Institute of Peace
Woodrow Wilson Center
World Bank
World Food Programme

Africa in Washington D.C.

Africa in Transition (Amb. John Campbell)
Africa in Washington, D.C.
African Arguments
China in Africa: The Real Story (Deborah Brautigam)
ChrisBlattman.com
Drew Hindshaw (West Africa correspondent)
Saxafi News
Somewhere in Africa (Shashank Bengali, Nairobi Bureau Chief, McClatchy Newspapers)
South of West: A Journalist Out of Africa (Rob Crilly)
The Green Nile (Andrew Scott)
Trend Lines (World Politics Review)