Showing posts with label Foreign Service. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Foreign Service. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 27, 2026

The Future of US Diplomacy and the Foreign Service

 The American Foreign Service Association posted on 26 October 2026 a one-hour podcast titled "Navigating Diplomacy in the Upside Down" with Nicholas Burns, retired Foreign Service Officer and ambassador to China during the Biden administration.  

This is a discussion with Ambassador Burns on diplomacy, foreign policy, the State Department under Republican and Democratic administrations, and the future of the U.S. Foreign Service.  

Thursday, October 8, 2026

Degradation of the US Foreign Service

The Conversation published on 7 October 2026 a commentary titled "Missing Ambassadors, Inexperienced Appointees--Is Washington Dropping the Diplomatic Ball?" by Donald Heflin, The Fletcher School, Tufts University, and former ambassador. 

Historically, about 30 percent of ambassadorial appointees are political and 70 percent career.  In the first Trump administration and the Biden administration the percentage of political appointees increased to 40 percent.  So far in the second Trump administration the percentage of political appointees has jumped to 80 percent and many of them are donors and personal friends with little overseas experience or knowledge of the country where they have been assigned.

Almost two years into the Trump administration, of the 196 U.S. ambassadorial positions, 92 remain vacant at a time when China and Russia are making an all-out effort to influence foreign governments.

Comment:  I was a Foreign Service Officer for 37 years, appointed ambassador by Presidents Reagan and Clinton.  It pains me to watch the decline of an organization where I spent most of my working career implementing the policies of Republican and Democratic administrations.  The comments by Donald Heflin capture only some of the damage done to the Foreign Service by Secretary of State Marco Rubio and the Trump administration.  It will take years, perhaps decades, to reverse the decline and restore the Foreign Service to the professional organization that has loyally served both Republican and Democratic administrations.  

And enough of this "deep state" nonsense.  Yes, government bureaucracies, including the Foreign Service, are often slow to adapt and sometimes lethargic in new policy implementation.  But they are not purposely thwarting an administration's directives and once there is new political leadership at the top of an agency, they fall in line.  In the rare case where someone refuses to carry out a new administration's policy, that individual is removed, pushed aside, or retires.  The argument that there is some secret, hostile organization within the bureaucracy opposing any administration is just a lot of trumpery.    

Thursday, September 17, 2026

The Decimation of the US Foreign Service

 Diplomacy Notebook posted on 16 September 2026 a commentary titled "Rebuilt After 9/11, U.S. Diplomacy Now Lies in Ruins" by Nicholas Kralev.

This is an account of the destruction since 9/11 of the U.S. Foreign Service, especially since the advent of the second Trump administration.  

Wednesday, August 12, 2026

Decline of the US State Department

 Small Wars Journal published on 11 August 2026 a commentary titled "The War of the Pen: What America's State Department Is Ignoring" by Julian McBride.

The author laments the absence of ambassadors at numerous US embassies, the State Department's waning soft power, the rise of middle and regional powers at the expense of the United States, and the increasing influence of China in the Global South.

He believes US diplomatic setbacks are self-inflicted but can be reversed through concerted action and the US position restored in the Global South.  

Sunday, July 26, 2026

The State Department and the Trump Administration

 The American Conservative published on 22 July 2026 a commentary titled "The Fight Inside Trump's State Department Is About Power--Not Expertise" by Phillip Linderman.

The author argues that the Trump administration is trying to salvage the US Foreign Service from the "globalist and woke values" that dominate professional diplomatic services.  But the "old guard" in the State Department is stymieing this effort in the belief that the situation in the Department will return to normal after Trump leaves office.

For decades, the State Department's machinery has reflexively favored the globalist or internationalist Foreign Service officer over the American First officer.  Now an administration is trying to rebalance the institution.   

The old guard understands that accepting Trump's approach would mean surrendering much of its power to shape foreign policy.  That is why its members defended "the corrupt and dysfunctional USAID."  He concludes: "This is a fight about Washington power, not diplomatic expertise."

Comment:  There is a grain of truth to the author's core argument.  Foreign Service officers tend to be globalist and internationalist in their approach to foreign affairs.  That has also been the approach of all post-World War II administrations with the exception of the first Trump administration.  Foreign Service officers, especially at the senior level, also want to have an impact on the foreign policy decision making process and not meekly parrot every decision that comes from on high.  

This is where his analysis falls apart.  There is a role for offering a slightly different approach or even a contrary point of view backed up by sound knowledge and analysis.  If it is not accepted, then obviously the decision from "on high" must be accepted.  In the vast majority of cases in my experience, this has been the response from the Foreign Service.  If significant differences remained, the Foreign Service officer was moved to a different position or resigned.  

A Foreign Service officer has every right to disagree, for example, with the author's definition of USAID as "corrupt and dysfunctional" because he is flat-out wrong and the administration erred in dismantling the organization.  But the Trump administration made the decision to shut USAID down, and it is up to the Foreign Service to implement the new policy on foreign assistance.  I suspect the overwhelming majority of Foreign Service officers today are doing just that.

The author argues that the "public record" suggests senior Foreign Service officers' reluctance to implement the president's decisions fully and faithfully is widespread.  The "public record" he cites is a flawed analysis titled "Why Does Trump Hate the State Department" published by The American Conservative on July 20 and reposted below on July 21.  


Monday, July 20, 2026

The Decline of Diplomacy in the United States

 USA Today published on 19 July 2026 an opinion piece titled "Reduction in US State Department Staff Was Purge in Diplomacy" by Elizabeth "Liz" Colton.

The Trump administration's dismissal of diplomacy and purge of the State Department have resulted in the predictable negative impact on US foreign policy.  

Friday, July 17, 2026

Picking Up the Pieces at the US State Department

 The Federal News Network published on 16 July 2026 an article titled "Laid-off Federal Employees Spotlight Impacts of State Dept. RIF" by Drew Friedman.

The State Department laid off nearly 1,350, mostly civil service, staff and DOGE fired almost all USAID personnel and abolished the organization, moving a small number of USAID employees to the State Department.  The State Department is now scrambling to figure out how to cope with issues such as Ebola in Africa.  

Wednesday, July 15, 2026

Crisis at the U.S. Department of State

 The Daily Beast published on 14 July 2026 an article titled "Insiders Expose Trump 'Crisis' at the State Department" by Ewan Palmer.

This is a devastating account of the current situation in the U.S. Department of State.  It draws heavily on a longer article in the UK's Financial Times.

Monday, July 13, 2026

Reversing DOGE Damage to State Department

 Federal News Network published on 10 July 2026 an article titled "State Dept. Is Looking to Rebuild after Major Staffing Cuts.  Laid-off Diplomats Say They Are Not Welcome Back" by Jory Heckman.

After arbitrarily firing 1,350 State Department employees last summer, the administration is now trying to hire staff so that the organization has the personnel to carry out the functions expected of it.

Comment: This is a classic example of how not to "reform" a large bureaucratic, governmental organization.   

Tuesday, June 2, 2026

Dismantling of Professional American Diplomacy

 The Daily Beast published on 1 June 2026 an article titled "Jaw-Dropping Brain Drain Under Trump Revealed" by Will Neal.

The Trump administration has either laid off or forced into retirement about 2,000 career diplomats since the beginning of 2025.  This figure does not include foreign service personnel who were fired when the administration dismantled the US Agency for International Development.  

More than half of US embassies do not have a Senate-confirmed ambassador and those that are staffed at the ambassadorial level include only 8 percent career ambassadors.  The vast majority of American ambassadors today are financial contributors to the Trump campaign, close friends of the administration, or family members. 

Monday, May 18, 2026

The Hollowing Out of the US State Department

 CNN published on 16 May 2026 an article titled "As Global Crises Multiply, Scores of US Diplomats Say They Have Been Forced Out" by Jennifer Hansler.

An estimated 2,000 Foreign Service officers have been forced out or left by their own choice the U.S. Department of State in the past year.  Of 195 ambassadorial positions overseas, 115 are currently vacant, an unprecedented situation this late in an administration.  

This hollowing out of the State Department will have far reaching implications for the ability of the United States to project power and deliver on its foreign policy priorities.

Thursday, January 15, 2026

The Unravelling of the U.S. Foreign Service

 Lawfare Daily published on 14 January 2026 an interview titled "The U.S. Foreign Service at a 'Breaking Point' with John Dinkelman."

John Dinkelman, president of the American Foreign Service Association and a 37-year veteran of the State Department, describes the dismal state of affairs in the U.S. Foreign Service today.

Comment:  I also spent 37-years in the U.S. Foreign Service, albeit in an earlier period than Dinkelman, and find it heart-breaking to learn what is happening to an organization that I love and respect.  

Tuesday, January 13, 2026

Career Officers Seeking Ambassadorships: Hibernate for at Least Three Years

 The National Journal published on 12 January 2026 an article titled "Trump's Ambassadors Are Largely Political Appointees" by Ledyard King.

As of January 1, 2026, 64 of the 70 nominated ambassadors--91 percent--have been political choices based on their ties to the Trump administration or the amount of money they donated to the Trump campaign.  In a normal administration, at the end of four years, the ratio is about two-thirds career officers and one-third political appointees.  

Comment:  While the percentage of political appointees to career officers may change over the next three years, the outlook for career Foreign Service officers is pretty dismal.  

Monday, January 5, 2026

The Administration's Campaign against Career Ambassadors

 The Mining Journal published on 2 January 2026 an editorial titled "Trump's Mass Firing of Diplomats a Danger to US Standing."

At full complement, the United States has about 195 ambassadorships.  Just before Christmas, the Trump administration fired 30 career ambassadors (as opposed to ambassadors appointed because of their political connections or campaign contributions).  When added to the already 79 ambassadorial vacancies, this means that more than half of America's ambassadorial positions are now vacant.  The editorial makes the point that so many ambassadorial vacancies provide an opportunity for adversaries like China and Russia to gain foreign policy advantages.

Comment:  The overwhelming number of ambassadors appointed by the Trump administration so far have been political appointees.  The prospect for career Foreign Service Officers to become ambassadors appears bleak, which contributes to the current demoralization of the career service.   

Tuesday, December 9, 2025

Destroying American Diplomacy

 The Steady State published on 5 December 2025 a commentary titled "Destroying American Diplomacy: Pulling Down Our First Line of Defense" by Charles A. Ray, who spent 20 years in the US Army and 30 years in the US State Department as a Foreign Service Officer and two-time ambassador.  

Ray details how the Trump administration, as it seeks to end the so-called "deep state," is destroying the State Department and US Foreign Service in the process.

Wednesday, December 3, 2025

U.S. Foreign Service at the Breaking Point

 The American Foreign Service Association (AFSA) posted on 3 December 2025 a survey titled "At the Breaking Point: The State of the U.S. Foreign Service in 2025."

AFSA polled all of its active-duty members and received a response from 2,100 or about one-third of the total.  The results reflect a crisis developing in the organization where I served for 37 years.  

Some 86 percent of respondents said changes in the workplace since January 2025 have affected their ability to advance U.S. diplomatic priorities.  A whopping 98 percent reported poor morale.  Nearly one-third reported changing their career plans since January 2025.

US State Department: How Not to Manage a Bureaucracy

 The New York Times published on 2 December 2025 an article titled "U.S. Diplomats Report Broken Morale and Abandoned Careers" by Michael Crowley.

A recent American Foreign Service Association (AFSA) survey of 2,100 State Department diplomats reported that 98 percent believe workplace morale has fallen since the Trump administration took power in January.  Only 1 percent reported an improvement in the situation in the State Department.  

CNN covered the same report on 3 December 2025 in an article titled "Trump Administration Changes Have Left US Diplomats Demoralized and Less Able to Do Their Jobs, Report Says" by Jennifer Hansler.

CNN quotes the president of AFSA as saying: "The Foreign Service--the very institution tasked with navigating our global interests--is being dismantled in real time."  Secretary of State Marco Rubio praised State Department personnel when he first arrived.  There is now a belief he has turned his back on them.  


Monday, July 28, 2025

State Department Firings Listed by Bureau and Office

 Federal News Network posted on 25 July 2025 an article titled "These Are the State Department Offices Hit Hardest by Widespread Layoffs" by Jory Heckman.

The State Department fired 1,350 employees earlier this month.  This is a detailed account of the number of fired employees in 31 bureaus and offices according to civil service or foreign service status.  

Wednesday, July 16, 2025

Thanks to Retired Admiral William H. McRaven

 The Washington Post published on 15 July 2025 a commentary titled "William H. McRaven: Cutting the State Department and USAID Will Put Every American at Risk,"

Retired Admiral McRaven, commander of the U.S. Special Operations Command from 2011 to 2014, praised the work of Foreign Service and USAID personnel at locations around the world, especially for their efforts to counter terrorism.  He singled out some by name and argued that the dismantlement of USAID and sharp personnel reductions at the State Department only jeopardize American national security.  

Monday, July 14, 2025

State Department Reduction in Force: How It Was Done and Reactions

 NBC News posted on 12 July 2025 an account titled "Veteran U.S. Diplomats Baffled after Mass Layoffs at State Department" by Abigail Williams.  

This is a report on the 11 July dismissal of more than 1,300 State Department civil and foreign service personnel.  It focuses on the way the State Department conducted the firings and the response of those fired and those who kept their jobs.